摘要(Abstract)：
大众传媒话语的覆盖范围、渗透深度塑造了极具影响的"符号压力环境",往往被误读为公众意见的一个显性信息指标,导致立法机关有足够的激励顺应媒体话语展开立法过程,力图以此证立对于民意的积极回应,形成基于信息的压力型立法。但是,媒体话语具有时效性、宣泄性、甚至是"群体极化"的面相,容易失却应有的冷静与客观。其压力之下生成的立法无法满足司法运作的可观察性、可检验性要求,也模糊了法律与其他社会秩序控制的职能界分。必须着眼于决策程序、技术模型选择等变量进行制度重构,重塑立法民主与立法科学。
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 吴元元;Wang Hao;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- 1 From the perspective of definiation tradition of communication study,the mass media has been classified into newspaper,magazine,broadcast,and television.At the time of entering into the age of the internet,the speed,depth and breadth of cyber communication rise sharply between traditional media,and the cyber media has thus become to“the Fifth Media”.The coexistence between cyber media and traditional media has the trend of integration.For this reason,the author deem the media mentioned earlier as a whole in order to inspect the establishment,development,and inner mechanism of pressure-type lawmaking.
- 2 Xie Hongfei,Legality of Legal Acts:The Influence of Public Law on the Validity of Legal Acts and Its Limitations,6 China Social Science 124,124-142(2007).
- 3 See AVINASH K.DIXIT,LAWLESSNESS AND ECONOMICS:ALTERNATIVE MODES OF GOVERNANCE(Princeton:Princeton University Pres,2004).
- 4 LAWMAKING IS ENDLESS AND SHOCKING,at http://news.163.com/special/00012Q9L/lifa090826.html(Last visited on August 5,2013).
- 5 Wu Yuanyuan,Information Ability and Pressure-type Legislation,1 China Social Science 147,147-159(2010).
- 6 ZHOU XUEGUANG,TEN LECTURES ON THE SOCIOLOGY OF ORGANIZATION,at 74-75(Tsinghua University Press,2003).
- 7 MARSHALL MCLUHAN UNDERSTANDING MEDIA:THE EXTENSIONS OF MAN,at 16-33(He Daokuan trans.,Translation Press,2011).
- 8 The spread of the technology analyzed in this paper is applicable to the processing of interviewing,editing,broadcasting,commenting with the social and public affairs.The topics that not involve the public affairs such as relaxation,entertainment,interests and life utility class are not in the range of the spread of technology.
- 9 WILBUR SCHRAMM AND WILLIAM E.PORTER,MEN,WOMEN,MESSAGES,AND MEDIA:UNDERSTANDING HUMAN COMMUNICATION,at 187(Peking University Press,2007).
- 10 Id.,188.
- 11 Id.
- 12 Id.,229.
- 13 WILBUR SCHRAMM AND WILLIAM E.PORTER,supra note 9,13.
- 14 WALTER LIPPMANN,L IBERTY AND THE NEWS,at 33(Princeton:Princeton University Press,2008).
- 15 Id.,226.
- 16 XUJING,PUBLIC OPINION,at 117 and 220-221(Peking University Press,2009).
- 17 CASS SUNSTEIN,INFOTOPIA,at 36-47(Huang Weiming trans.,Shanghai People's Press,2003).
- 18 ROBERT C.ELLICKSON,ORDER WITHOUT LAW:HOW NEIGHBORS SETTLE DISPUTES,at130-131(Cambridge and London:Harvard University Press,1991).
- 19 ZHANG WEIYING,INFORMATION TRUST AND LAW,at 196(Sanlian Book Store,2003).
- 20 MICHEL FOUCAULT,ABOUT THE CONCEPT OF THE“DANGEROUS INDIVIDUAL”IN LEGAL PSYCHIATRY,Volume 2,Issue 2,at 494-495(Law Press,2000).
- 21 ZHANG WEIYING,supra note 20,197.
- 22 Avner Greif,Reputation and Coalitions in Medieval Trade:Evidence on Maghribi Traders,49Journal of Economic History 857,857-882(1989).
- 23 Stewart Macaulay,Non-Contractual Relations in Business:A Preliminary Study,28 American Sociological Review 55,55-67(1963).
- 24 MASAHI KO AOKI,COMPARATIVE INSTITUIONAL ANALYSIS,at 84(Zhou Lian trans.,Shanghai Yuandong Press,2001).
- 25 Id.,85.
- 26 ROBERT C.ELLICKSON,supra note 19,258-264.
- 27 Ramon Casadesus-Masanell and Daniel Spulbe,Trust and Incentives in Agency,15 Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal 43,43-103(2005)
- 28 ROBERT ELLICKSON,ORDER WITHOUT LAW:HOW NEIGHBORS SETTLE DISPUTES,at 286(Harvard University Press,1991).
- 29 RICHARD A.POSNER,OVERCOMING LAW,at 269(Harvard University Press,1995).
- 30 Lu Wenjie,The Standing Committee of the Guangzhou People's Congress Issueed the Local Legislation Guide for Public Participation,Guangzhou Daily,March 1,2013.
- 31 LUO AIHUA,GUANGDONG INTRODUCED THE FIRST LOCAL GOVERNMENT RUGULATIONS OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND ADMINISTRATIVE LEGISLATION,at http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2006-07/11/content_4816153.html(Last visited on July 18,2013).
- 32 Wang Xixin and Zhang Yongle,Experts,the Public and Use of Knowledge:An Analytical Frame Work for Administrative Rule Making,3 China Social Science 113,113-127(2010).
- 33 Id.
- 34 ROBERT A.BARON&DONN BYRNE,SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY,at 652(Huang Min et al.trans.,Huangdong Normal University,2004).
- 35 SU LI,HOW TO ANALYSZE MORAL AND UNDERSTAND LAW,Preface for the Problematics of Moral and Legal Theory(Chinese Edition),(China University of Political Science and Law Press,2001).
- 36 Ma Yingjuan,Commentary on the Impact Analysis System of the U.S.Supervision,1 Studied in Law and Business 98,98-106(2008).
- 37 Xi Tao,Legislation Evaluation:What need to be Evaluated and How to Evaluate–Take the Chinese Legislation Assessment as Example,5 Tribune of Political Science and Law 59,59-75(2012).
- 38 ZHOU XUEGUANG,supra note 6,89.
- 39 In the prosess of lawmaking,the law drafting is a basic link with knowledge content,and has been generally deemed as a work with high technological requirements.Although the draft will be published to the whole society before enacting and taking into effect in order to let the public to participate in,discuss and make suggestions for revision,the intellectual level of law drafting will the first pass of directly determining the performance of law enforcement,justice and law abiding.
