摘要(Abstract)：
I.INTRODUCTION Criminal judgments are the judicial documents that the people’s courts,taking the law as a criterion,deliver to the defendants in accordance with the ascertained facts after conducting the trials of the criminal cases.A good judgment is supposed to reason thoroughly,elaborate comprehensively,and fully
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation): the staged achievement of the Social Science Research Funding of Beijing(15FXB010);;
the Rule of Law and Legal Theory Research Project(14SFB5003)
作者(Author): 张清;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- (1)Long Zongzhi,Improving the Legal Reasoning in the Criminal Judgments,2 Modern Law Science,35-41(1999).
- (2)SUN HUAPU,WANG LIMING&MA LAIKE,LEGAL REASONING IN ADJUDICATION,TRANSPARENCY,JUSTICE AND CREDIBILITY,at 1(Peking University Press,2016).
- (3)THE FOURTH FIVE YEAR OUTLINE OF THE REFORM OF THE PEOPLE’S COURT(2014-2018),at http://www.chinalawedu.com/falvfagui/21752/wa1502273796.shtml(Last visited on January 22,2018).
- (4)CHINA JUDGMENTS ONLINE,at http://wenshu.court.gov.cn/(Last visited on June 1,2018).
- (5)BO XILAI WAS SENTENCED TO LIFE IMPRISONMENT IN THE FIRST AND SECOND TRIALS(FULL TEXT OF THEJUDGMENT),at http://www.360doc.com/content/13/0922/17/3595709_316265159.shtml(Last visited on April 5,2018).
- (6)This judgment was derived from the library electronic databases of China University of Political Science and Law“LexisN exis”[Online]Available Telnet,at http://origin-www.lexisnexis.com/ap/auth/(Last visited on July 15,2017).Since American legal reasoning is very long,this essay only excerpts several passages.
- (7)App.to Pet.for Cert.12-13.
- (8)Hudson Valley Freedom Theater,Inc.v.Heimbach,671 F.2d 702,706(CA2 1982).
- (9)Guides,Ltd.v.Yarmouth Group Prop.Management,Inc.,295 F.3d 1065,1072-1073(CA10 2002).
- (10)107 Fed.Appx.18(2004).
- (11)698 F.2d 1019,1021-1022(1983).
- (12)107 Fed.Appx.,at 18-19.
- (13)544 U.S.998,544 U.S.998,125 S.Ct.1928,161 L.Ed.2d 772(2005).
- (14)42 U.S.C.§1981(a).
- (15)Id.,§1981(b).
- (16)S.Livermore,A Treatise on the Law of Principal and Agent 215(1818).
- (17)TIERSMA,PETER M&LAWRENCE M.SOLAN,THE OXFORD HANDBOOK OF LANGUAGE AND LAW,at 28(OxfordUniversity Press,2012).
- (18)THE NOTICE OF THE SUPREME PEOPLE’S COURT ON PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTING THE FORM OF CRIMINALPROCEDURE DOCUMENT IN THE COURT,at http://www.chinalawedu.com:8080/falvfagui/fg23079/1767.shtml(Last visited onJanuary 22,2018).
- (19)In America,judges or justices are used at different levels of courts.Nevertheless,the author just uses judge or judges to indicate all relevantjudge(s)or justice(s)in this paper.
- (20)Cao Jianhou,On Drafting the Legal Reasoning in the Criminal Judgments,12 Law Science 16-18(1984).
- (21)THE FINAL JUDGMENT OF FRAUD CASE OF SUN YINYUN,at http://www.pkulaw.cn/fulltext_form.aspx?Db=pfnl&Gid=120180099&keyword=%e5%ad%99%e9%93%b6%e4%ba%91&EncodingN ame=&Search_Mode=accurate(Last visited on July 15,2015).
- (22)QI JUN,LEGAL ENGLISH TEXTBOOK,at 97-98(Higher Education Press,2005).
- (23)§1897 of the Penal Law.
- (24)Code Cr.Proc.§528.
- (25)People v.Molineux,168 N.Y.264(1901)
- (26)Zhang Zhiming,The Structure and Style of Judicial Judgments:the Comparative Study on the Extraterritorial Judicial Practice,10 LegalScience 25-31(1998).
- (27)Wang Zhongyun,Study on the Legal Reasoning of Judgments,8 Shandong Social Sciences 84-86,156(2015).
- (28)HE JIAHONG,FOREIGN JUDICIAL PRECEDENT SYSTEMS,at 70-82(China Legal Publishing House,2014).
- (29)Zhang Qing&Gong Mingyu,A Comparative Study of Modality in American and Chinese Criminal Judgments,1 Journal of ShanxiUniversity(Philosophy and Social Science Version I)82-87(2013).
- (30)SUN HUAPU,WANG LIMING&MA LAIKE,supra note 2,13.
- (31)More guiding cases may have persuasive effect on future similar cases with the Case Guidance System adopted in China.
- (32)Lin Yan,How to Follow the Precedents in American Courts,6 Peking University Law Journal 951-957(2009).
- (33)HE JIAHONG,supra note 15.
- (34)DURANT,ALAN&JANNY HC LEUNG,LANGUAGE AND LAW,at 69(Routledge,2016).
- (35)Kang Li,The First Discussion about the Reasoning of Sentencing,11 Criminal Science 80-86(2008).
- (36)ZHOU KAI,HOW TO DRAFT BETTER JUDGMENTS:WRITING,COMMENTS AND IMPROVEMENTS IN REAL CASES,at1-6(China University of Political Science and Law Press,2010).
- (37)Id.,1-6.
- (38)NING ZHIYUAN,THE EXPLORATION OF LEGAL INSTRUMENTS AND LEGAL LANGUAGE,at 173-175(China Universityof Political Science and Law Press,2007).
- (39)Zhang Zhiming,supra note 13.
- (40)Wan Yi&Liu Xifen,From“Unreasonable”Judgments to Judgments with“Reasoning”:the Analysis of Justification of Reasoning Systemin Judgments,5 Legal Forum 29-34(2004).
- (41)SUN HUAPU,WANG LIMING&MA LAIKE,supra note 2.
