摘要(Abstract)：
证据以及证据规则在事实认定上起着至关重要的作用。证据是认识案件事实的第一来源,如果证据发生变化,最终的事实文本必然发生重大变化。由于传统的关于案件事实的讨论只关注证据而忽视叙事建构,如果用传统法学理论观察案件事实,我们会感受到证据与事实文本之间存在某种断裂地带,可是这种断裂又不为人所承认,这样的矛盾将导致在证据与事实间的认识、推理问题上,得出一些模糊混乱的理解。笔者因此尝试在这个阶段提出一个推进式的理论框架来弥补这种认识上的断裂感。
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation): supported by the Opening Project of Key Laboratory of Evidence Science(China University of Political Science and Law)granted by the Ministry of Education(2016KFKT09)
作者(Author): 张鲁平;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- 1 Criminal Judgment of the First Intermediate People's Court,Beijing(2006)No.3500,Yi Zhong Criminal Chu Zi.
- 2 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT OF CUI YINGJIE CASE HEARD IN THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT,BEIJING,DECEMBER 12,2006,at http://tiebabaidu.com/p/226845523(Last visited on March 1,2015).
- 3 Id.
- 4 BERND RUTHERS,JURISPRUDENCE,at 298(Ding Xiaochun&Wu Yue trans.,Law Press,2003).
- 5 SU LI,SPREADING LAW TO THE COUNTRYSIDE,at 162(China University of Political Science and Law Press,2000).
- 6 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT OF CUI YINGJIE CASE HEARD IN THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT,supra note 2.
- 7 Indictment of the First Branch of Beijing People's Procuratorate,No.243,Jing JianYi Fen Criminal Prosecution(2006).
- 8 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT OF CUI YINGJIE CASE HEARD IN THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT,supra note 2.
- 9 Id.
- 10 Id.
- 11 Criminal Judgment of the First Intermediate People's Court,supra note 1.
- 12 At http://www.bjcg.gov.cn/cgxw/ztxx/lzqzt/yyzl/index.htm(Last visited on August 2,2007).
- 13 Id.
- 14 Prosecution Opinions of the Public Security Bureau,Beijing,No.516 Jing Gong Yu Su Zi.
- 15 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT OF CUI YINGJIE CASE HEARD IN THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT,supra note 2.
- 16 Id,
- 17 YANG JIANJUN,INTERPREATION OF LEGAL FACT,at 143(Shandong People's Press,2007).
- 18 Zhang Bin,A Jurisprudence Retrospect on Evidence Methods,6 Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities(Social Sciences Edition)(2003).
- 19 Id,60,64.
- 20 YANG JIANJUN,INTERPRETATIONS OF LEGAL FACT,at 126(Shandong People's Press,2007).
- 21 Nancy Pennington&Reid Hastie,Explaining the Evidence:Test of the Story Model for Juror Decision Making,62(2)Personality and Social Psychology 189-206(1992).NANCY PENNINGTON&REID HASTIE,THE STORY MODEL FOR JUROR DECISION MAKING,in INSIDE THE JUROR,at 84-115(Reid Hastie ed.,Cambridge University Press,1993).
- 22 Id.
- 23 Id.
- 24 Id.
- 25 Indictment of the First Branch of Beijing People's Procuratorate,supra note 7.
- 26 Lynda Olsen-Fulero&Solomon M.Fulero,Commonsense Rape Judgments:An Empathy-Complexity Theory of Rape Juror Story Making,3(2-3)Psychology,Public Policy and Law 402-42(1997).
- 27 Id.
- 28 Id.
- 29 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT OF CUI YINGJIE CASE HEARD IN THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT,supra note 2,
- 30 Nancy Pennington&Reid Hastie,supra note 22.
- 31 Id.
