摘要(Abstract)：
随着非法证据排除制度的出台及其适用,重复言词证据排除问题随之浮出水面,一次非法取证行为,是否意味着受其影响紧随其后的一系列取证行为的"非法",这就关系到重复言词证据的排除问题。排除重复言词证据已经成为有效实施非法证据排除规则的必然要求,而且非法证据的排除是认定重复言词证据可采性的必经程序,是排除重复言词证据的关键,但是司法实践中法院对非法证据排除所持的消极不作为态度以及现阶段我国法院系统与公安、检察系统的"同质性"等现实问题又意味着排除重复言词证据必将面临重重障碍,另外,我国司法实践中法官自由裁量权的制约以及冤错案的频发,要求重复言词证据的排除必须坚持绝对排除原则,而依据法官自由裁量权决定排除范围的方法是不可行的。
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 田荔枝;权艳平;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- 1 Tian Wenchang and Zou Jiaming,Issues of the Exclusion of Illegal Verbal Evidences,7 The People’s Judicature 67(2013).
- 2 Xie Xiaojian,On Exclusionary Rules about Repeated Statements,1 Legal Forum 110,(2012).
- 3 LI XINGUI AND LI JINHUI,THE CRIMINAL ALARM BELL:STUDIES ON THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF TORTURE,at 105(Law Press of China,2012).
- 4 ZHENG XU,THE EXCLUSIONARY RULE OF ILLEGAL EVIDENNCE,at 138(China Legal Publishing House,2009).
- 5 TAGUCHI MOCHI,THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW,at 245(Liu Di,Zhang Ling,and Mu jin trans.,Law Press of China,2000).
- 6 Long Zongzhi,Study on Several Problems of the Regulation and Execution of the Two Provisions of Evidences,6 China Legal Science 22(2010).
- 7 Tian Wenchang and Zou Jiaming,supra note 1,68.
- 8 TIAN WENCHANG AND CHEN RUIHUA,CHINESE CRIMINAL DEFENSE EXPERIENCES,at 425(Peking University Press,2013).
- 9 This view is hold by Professor Sun Changyong.See Wang Biao,On Exclusion of Pre-trial Repeated Confession,5 Evidence Science 596(2013).
- LIN YUXIONG,THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW,at 150(China Renmin University Press,2005).
- Wan Yi,On the Effect of Repeated Confessions,5 Journal of Sichuan University(Social Science Edition)140(2011).
- Tian Wenchang and Zou Jiaming,supra note 1,68.
- Wan Yi,supra note 11,143.
- According to a investigation to the prisoners of seven prison in four province,the ratio of the suspects who suffered direct torture in the pre-trial stage is 55.3%,and the ratio of suspects who suffered indirect torture is 60.1%.See Lin Lihong,Yin Quan and Huang Qihui,The Research on Torture in Current Situation:Take the Prisoners as Respondents,3 Journal of Hubei University of Police 76(2010)
- Supra note 13,140.
- CHEN RUIHUA,VISIBLE JUSTICES,at 133(Peking University Press,2013).
- Wang Biao,On Exclusion of Pre-trial Repeated Confession,5 Evidence Science 604(2013).
- Yan Zhaohua,Exclusion of Evidence and Successive Confessions,2 Modern Law Science 125(2013).
- YAN ZHAOHUA,CONFESSION CENTRISM RESEARCH,at 395(Law Press of China,2013).
- MA BAOJIN,LI MING AND JIANG SHIPING,THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE,at 12(People’s Publishing House,2006).
- ZHANG JUN,JIANG WEI AND TIAN WENCHANG,THE CRIMINAL LAW-THE TRIPARTITE TALKS OF THE PROSECUTION,THE DEFENCE AND THE TRIAL,at 170(Law Press of China,2001).
- THE EXAMINATION INDEX OF THE RATIO OF GUILTY VERDICT AND SO ON WILL BE CANCELED,JINGHUA NEWS,at http://epaper.jinghua.cn/html/2015-01/22/content_163892.htm(Last visited on Jan.22,2015)
