摘要(Abstract)：
能源财产交易的客体是能源财产交易制度的重要内容,结合我国能源市场的实际情况,包括能源产品和能源资源利用权。能源资源所有权是能源财产交易客体的母权,明确了能源资源的归属,才能在此基础上对能源资源加以利用,并由此衍生而出能源产品和能源资源利用权。其中,能源产品的财产权化和市场准入制度,使得能源产品价值的确定成为交易的核心,如何通过市场定价和政府调控相结合的方式,形成合理的能源产品价格是本文讨论的重点问题。此外,能源资源利用权作为一种财产权利,具有一定的边界,本文从权利的对象和权利的内容入手进行剖析,对能源资源利用权的判断标准提出了自己的见解,并针对权利冲突问题提出了相应的解决建议。简而言之,通过对能源财产交易客体的全面结构分析,为我国能源财产交易制度的市场化改革提供了理论支持。
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation): supported by Program for Young Innovative Research Team in China University of Political Science and Law(Project Number:2014CXTD05)
作者(Author): 郑佳宁;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- 1 ZHANG WENXIAN,GENERAL THEORY OF PHILOSOPHY OF LAW,at 252(Liaoning People’s Publishing House,2009).
- 2 Qiao Xinsheng,Transaction Object:Law and Economics Analysis,3 Hebei Law Science 19(2000).
- For example,in the United Kingdom the rules stipulate that apart from gold and silver,the land owner shall claim ownership for all the other mineral resources.In the United States,the land owners are the owners of energy resources.Since the land is owned by federal government,states and private persons,the energy resources,consequently,are allotted to federal government,states and private persons.See ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES AND ENERGY LAW RESEARCH CENTER OF TSINGHUA UNIVERSITY,EXPERTS’ADVICE AND EXPLANATION CHINA ENERGY LAW(DRAFT),at 26-27(Tsinghua University Press,2008).
- Id.,for example,the Federal Mining Act in Germany classifies energy resources into two,Bergfrei and Grundeigen,which are owned by different subjects.The former is owned by the State,the latter the land owners.
- KELSEN,GENERAL THEORY OF LAW AND STATE,at 227(Shen Zongling trans.,Encyclopedia of China Publishing House,1996).
- Zheng Jianing,Form Administrative Management to Comprehensive Management:Energy Management System Reform in China,3 Administrative Law Review 12(2010).
- Su Miaohan,Legal and Institutional Research on Universal Energy Service,10 Research on Rule of Law 13-18(2007).
- For instance,since 2005,security fund for urban heating systems has been established in China’s northern cities for the low-income,and the subsidies are given proportionally on the basis of their financial status.
- YIN TIAN,REAL RIGHT LAW,at 34-40(Peking University Press,2013).
- Cui Jianyuan,Theoretical Problems of Quasi-Property,3 Chinese Legal Science 82(2003).
- JIANG PING,REAL RIGHT LAW,at 231&262-263(Law Press,2009).Construction land use right refers that a person who enjoys the right shall,according to law,possess,use and benefit from the land owned by the State,and shall have the right to use the land for erecting buildings and structures and the facilities attached to them.Maritime area use right refers that a person who enjoys the right shall,according to law,possess,use and benefit from the maritime area owned by the State,and shall have the right to use the sea for fishing,breeding,sailing and so on.
- The Energy Law of China(Draft),Chapter III,Section II“Market Threshold”.
- ZHANG YONG,BASIC RESEARCH ON ENERGY LAW,at 226(Law Press,2011).
- Supra note 12,article 87.
- ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES AND ENERGY LAW RESEARCH CENTER OF TSINGHUA UNIVERSITY,supra note 3,46.
- Nrin Deway,Why Sunset Provisions Harm the Renewable Energy Industry and the Violate Tax Principles,5 Boston College Law Review 1105-1146(2011).
- The Decision on Major Issues Concerning Comprehensively Deepening Reforms was adopted at the close of the Third Plenary Session of the 18th CPC Central Committee in November 12th 2013.According to Item 10 of Part III—Modern Market System,it demands to perfect a mechanism where prices are determined by the market,including the price reforms of water,oil and natural gas,electricity,etc.
- The Notice of the National Energy Administration on Effectively Conducting the Work on Grid:Connected and Consumption of Wind Power was issued by the National Energy Administration in2013.
- Ma Junju&Gong Xiangqian,On the Reform of Energy Law,3 China Legal Science 192(2007).
- Wen Guifang,The Target of Energy Price Reform is to Establish a Scientific and Rational Pricing Mechanism,24 China Economic and Trade Herald 18(2009).
- Ye Zhaomu,Research Progress,Problems and Prospect of Environmental Loss and Environmental Cost Evaluation,1 Sichuan Environment 85-89(2007).
- HUANG ZHENZHONG,ZHAO QIUYAN&TAN BAIPING,STUDIES OF CHINA ENERGY LAW,at 95(Law Press,2009).
- Xu Chaojun,Luo Nengsheng&Wang Liangjian,A Summary and Development Direction of The Research on Property Rights of Mineral Resources in China,1 China Mining Magazine 21(2007).
- Zhang Zhongmin,Preliminary Analysis on Energy Resources Development Contract,8 Environmental and Resources Law Review 80(2010).
- CUI JIANYUAN,STUDY ON QUASI-PROPERTY,at 185(Law Press,2003).
- The Rules for Implementation of the Mineral Resources Law,article 6.
- Zheng Jianing,On the Institution of Energy Property Mortgage in China,11 Zhejiang Social Sciences77-78(2013).
- XIE ZAIQUAN,REAL RIGHT OF CIVIL LAW,Vol.1,at 9-18(China University of Political Science and Law Press,Fifth Edition,2011).
- The Heilongjiang Province Climate Resources Exploration and Protection Regulation,article 3(2).
- Zhuang Jinghua,Climate Resources State Ownership is not China’s Original Creation,6 Journal of China University of Political Science and Law 33-38(2012).
- Li Yanfang,Evaluation on Heilongjiang Province Climate Resources Exploration and Protection Regulation,9 Wind Energy 29-33(2012).
- ZHANG YONG,BASIC RESEARCH ON ENERGY LAW,at 4(Law Press,2011).
- The Property Rights Law of the PRC,article 33,34,35,36 and 37.
- A·JM.MILNE,HUMAN RIGHTS AND HUMAN DIVERSITY:PHILOSOPHY OF HUMAN RIGHTS,at 148(Zhang Zhiming&Xia Yong trans.,Encyclopedia of China Publishing House,1995).
- Su Li,Lawsuit in Story of Qiuju,Khoo Rat Poison Case and Freedom of Speech,3 Chinese Journal of Law 67(1996).
- Li Changqing,Analysis of Rights Conflict,3 Modern Law Science,39-45(2005).
- Liu Zuoxiang,Several Theoretical Problems of Rights Conflict,2 China Legal Science 57-58(2002).
- Hu Jian,The Conflict between Mining Rights of Oil and Gas Resources and Land Property Rights:A Case Study on the Development of Oil and Gas Resources in North Shanxi,3 Resources Science 8-16(2007).
- See The Mineral Resources Law Implementation Rules,the Regulation on the Registration of Exploration Blocks for Mineral Resources,and the Regulation on the Registration of Mining of Mineral Resources.
- Qin Yang,Hu Shi&Zhang Xiaolong,The Conflict of Rights and Settlement Mechanism of Oil and Gas Mineral Rights in China,1 Ecological Economy 70(2012).
- See Article 2 of the Mineral Resources Law Implementation Rules,article 4 of the Regulation on the Registration of Exploration Blocks for Mineral Resources,and article 3 of the Regulation on the Registration of Mining of Mineral Resources.
- Hu Hairong,Causes and Countermeasures for Mining Rights Dispute over Coal and Coal-Bed Methane,7 East China Economic Management 71-71(2008).
- LUO WEIQI,STUDY ON THE RESOLUTION MECHANISM FOR CONFLICTS BETWEEN MINING RIGHTS AND LAND PROPERTY RIGHTS,at 18(Dissertation for Master Degree,Petroleum University,2011).
- If an energy resources use right holder wants to use the collective owned land,the collectively owned land should first be expropriated by the state,and then the state should transfer the pertaining construction land use right to the right holder.
- WANG JIN,STUDY ON ENVIRONMENTAL LAW,at 65(Peking University Press,2011).
- ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES AND ENERGY LAW RESEARCH CENTER OF TSINGHUA UNIVERSITY,supra note 3,187.
- XING HONG,INNOVATION OF POLLUTION CONTROL STRATEGY:EMISSION TRADING AND ITS LEGAL REGULATION,at 46-47(South China University of Technology Press,2007).
- KARL LARENZ,LEGAL METHODOLOGY,at 35(Chen Ai’e trans.,Commercial Press,2003).
- The Mineral Resources Law of China,article 20.
- Cao Gang,The Moral Solution to the Conflict of Right:On the Conflict between the Emission Right and the Environmental Right,6 Journal of Renmin University of China 117(2011).
- Wan Jun,Build the Resolution Mechanism for the Conflicts between Mining Rights and Land Property Rights,6 Yunnan Geographic Environment Research,89(2005).
- COOTER,ROBERT,THOMAS ULEN,LAW AND ECONOMICS,at 107(Mu Xianqing&Fang Zhiwei trans.,Shanghai University of Finance and Economics Press,2002).
