摘要(Abstract)：
行政自由裁量权概念的发达除客观需要之外,还有人为的因素,为行政扩张服务甚至为了逃避司法审查。然而,行政自由裁量权是一个可以被内化或转化甚至淹没的概念,虽然它是事先确定的一个指引但却是一个错误的指引。国家主权理论的衰微,行政权的弱化,行政种类多样,裁量空间的压缩以及部分裁量被"不确定法律概念"涵摄,行政自由裁量权风光不再。让行政自由裁量权概念在行政法领域尽快消失。以行政法的"裁量性规范",将行政"裁量性事实"放在行政行为下考量,通过对其目的性、公益性以及合法性进行的判断,使其获得正当性基础。行政诉讼以是否应该作为、是否超越职权、是否滥用职权为司法审查内容,以确认判决、撤销判决、确认无效判决为判决方式,取消现行的变更判决。
关键词(KeyWords)：
Abstract:
Keywords:
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 张弘;Li Xiaoning;Li Chao;
Email:
参考文献(References)：
- 1 YU LINGYUN,ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION,at 1(Chinese People's Public Security University Press,2005).
- 2 Charles H.Koch,Judicial Review of Administrative Discretion,54 George Washington Law Review469,469(1986).
- 3 Liu Yan,Going down from the Altar of Discretion:Rethinking on Kaili Case and the Issue on the“Discretion”,5 Peking University Law Journal 540,540-570(2002).
- 4 Guan Baoying,Rethinking on the Obviously Unfair in Administrative Actions,7 Political Science and Law 71,71-79(2009).
- 5 Yang Jianshun,The Operation of Administrative Discretion and Its Supervision,1 Chinese Journal of Law 1,1-15(2004).
- 6 DALIAN CITY CANCELS THE DISCRETION IN FORESTRY ADMINISTRATIVE PUNISHMENT,at http://dl.people.com.cn/GB/channel2/16/200810/12/88335.html(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 7 ALBERT VENN DICEY,AN INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY OF THE LAW OF THE CONSTITUTION,at 188(Indianapolis:Liberty Fund,1959).
- 8 WENG YUESHENG,THE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND THE MODERN STATES UNDER THE RULE OF LAW,at 42(Taiwan Xiangxin Printing Co.,Ltd.,1990).
- 9 DAVID M.WALKER,THE OXFORD COMPANION TO LAW,at 261(Deng Zhenglai trans.,Guangming Daily Press,1988).
- 10 WILLIAM WADE AND CHRISTOPHER FORSYTH,ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 35(Oxford University Press,2009).
- 11 SUN XIAOXIA,THE CONTROL OF LAW ON ADMINISTRATION,at 278(Shandong People's Publishing House,1999).
- 12 JIANG HONGZHEN,THE STRICT ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS AND THE DISCRETIONARY ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS in ON THE BASIC SCOPE OF ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS,at 94-98(Zhejiang University Press,2005).
- 13 GUAN BOAYING,THE COURSE OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES,at 71(China University of Political Science and Law Press,2001).
- 14 WILLIAM WADE,ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 63(Xu Bing trans.,Encyclopedia Publishing House,1997).
- 15 ARISTOTLE,POLITICAL SCIENCE,at 199(Wu Shoupeng trans.,The Commercial Press,1965).
- 16 YU LINGYUN,supra note 1,35.
- 17 WANG ZHENYU,STRENGTHENING THE JUDICIAL REVIEW ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION,at http://www.21gwy.com/lunwen/xzf/a/5341/PageGwy4_755341.html 2012-08-19(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 18 Id.
- 19 XIAO JINMING,THE LOGIC OF LEGAL ADMINISTRATION,at 258(China University of Political Science and Law Press,2004).
- 20 Shang Shuili,The Substantive Issues of Administrative Discretion,3 The Journal of National Institute of Public Administration 59,59-63(2012).
- 21 WILLIAM WADE,supra note 14,55.
- 22 ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION,at http://wenku.baidu.com/view/906c6b87e53a580216 fcfe7d.html(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 23 HARTMUT MAURER,THE SUMMARY OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 125(Gao Jiawei trans.,THE Law Press,2000).
- 24 Liu Zhijian and Song Xiaoling,Logical Thinking on Classification of Strict Administrative Acts and Discretionary Acts,2 Journal of Northwest Normal University(Social Sciences)111,111-116(2011).
- 25 Wang Ping,On the Administrative Discretion and Its Legal Control,8 The Guide of Science&Education171,171-172(2011).
- 26 Id.
- 27 The French Constitution of 1791,Title Ⅲ,1.
- 28 LEON DUGUIT,THE TRANSFORMATION OF PUBLIC LAW,at 3(Zheng Ge trans.,China Legal Publishing House,2010).
- 29 Hong Zhang,Constitution The Right to Judicial Relief and Civil Society Draw,6 Northern Legal Science 21,21-28(2009).
- 30 HUANG XIAOXIAO,EXECUTIVE POWER AND ITS BASIC IDEA OF SOCIALIZATION,at http://theory.people.com.cn/GB/49150/49152/6064042.html(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 31 FAN YANG,ON ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 5-8(China Founder Press,2005).
- 32 HARTMUT MAURER,supra note 23,8-9.
- 33 LI JIEKE,THE CANCEL OF OF THE DISCRETION WILL ELIMINATE THE SPACE OF ABUSING RIGHTS,at http://news.sina.com.cn/c/pl/2006-09-27/114111118521.shtml(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 34 ZANG ZHIYUAN,THE RISING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION STANDARDS AND ITS REALISTIC TASKS,at http://www.doc88.com/p-412724541599.html(Last visited on December30,2013).
- 35 WEN YUESHENG,supra note 8.
- 36 CHEN XINMIN,THE PRINCIPLES OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW IN CHINA,at 148(China University of Political Science Press,2002).
- 37 ZHOU YOUYONG AND DENG XIAOBING,A COMPARATIVE OBSERVATION ON THE CONCEPT ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION,at http://www.studa.net/xingzhengfa/080519/17380634.html(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 38 THE ADMINISTRATIVE VERDICT OF THE FIRST INTERMEDIATE PEOPLE'S COURT OF BEIJING,at http://vip.chinalawinfo.com/case/(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 39 Yang Haikun,On the Administrative Discretion of Administrative Authorities and Its Control in Administrative Law,2 Social Sscience Front Bimonthly 137,137-141(1988).
- 40 RICHARD B.STEWART:RECONSTRUCTION OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 29(Shen Kui trans.,The Commercial Press,2002).
- 41 Id.
- 42 WENG YUESHENG,supra note 8,1.
- 43 YE BIFENG,ON THE EFFICACY OF ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS,at 12-13(China Renmin University Press,2002).
- 44 LEON DUGUIT,ON CONSTITUTION,at 222(Qian Kexin trans.,The Commercial Press,1962).
- 45 Id.,252-253.
- 46 ZHANG HONG,RETHINKING ON THE INFLUENCE OF ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES TO THE CHINA ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at http://www.xwlunwen.com/fllunwen/xzflw/9299.html(Last visited on December 30,2013).
- 47 Wang Xixin,The Standards of the Discretion:Technological Innovation or Misuse,5 Chinese Journal of Law 36,36-48(2008).
- 48 HE HAIBO,SUBSTANTIVE NOMOCRACY:TO SEEK THE LEGALITY OF ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGMENT,at 180(The Law Press,2009).
- 49 Wang Guisong,On the Purpose of Administrative Actions,1 The Journal of Zhejiang Administrative Cadre Institute of Politics and Law 32,32-35(2001).
- 50 Yu Lingyun,Improper Review on the Purpose of Administrative Discretion,5 Law and Social Development 75,75-80(2003).
- 51 WANG ZHENYU,supra note 17.
- 52 WU GEN,THEORETICAL AND PRACTICAL ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 521(San Min Book Co.,Ltd.,1996).
- 53 Zhang Hong and Guo Shengao,Identification and Remedy for Administrative Flaw Action,2 Journal of Liaoning University 143,143-147(2007).
- 54 HE HAIBO,ADMINISTRATIVE LAW,at 427(The Law Press,2011).
